Between low self-discharge NiMH and alkaline cells, 13 of the 16 characteristics in the full table below differ; one is the same and 2 can’t be compared because our sources give no figure or rating for one or both.
Rechargeable
NiMH low self-discharge
1.2 V · 84 Wh/kg · 2,100 cycles
An AA or AAA you can recharge up to 2,100 times that still holds 70 % after 10 years in a drawer.
Watch out: 1.2 V instead of 1.5 V: a few devices show a low battery early. Panasonic advises against devices with airtight battery compartments.
Single use (primary)
Alkaline
1.5 V · Single use
1.5 V, sold everywhere and 10 years on the shelf: fine for low-drain devices you rarely touch.
Watch out: The usable capacity depends strongly on the load, it works only down to −18 °C, and it is single use.
Full comparison
Feature
NiMH low self-discharge
Alkaline
Differences (13)
Basics
Type
Rechargeable
Single use (primary)
Nominal voltage
1.2 V
1.5 V
Voltage range
0.9 V (empty) to 1.4 V (full)
1.5 V nominal; Energizer’s tests stop at 0.8 V
Formats
AA and AAA
AA, AAA, C, D and 9 V
Example (source of the figures)
Panasonic eneloop AA
Energizer E91 (AA)
Energy
Energy per kilogram
84 Wh/kg
No single figure: the capacity depends strongly on the load (Energizer gives it as a chart)
Energy per litre
273 Wh/L
No single figure: the capacity depends strongly on the load (Energizer gives it as a chart)
Life and storage
Cycle life
Up to 2,100 (IEC 61951-2:2011); 600 with the 2017 method (Panasonic)
Single use
Self-discharge and storage
70 % left after 10 years at 20 °C (Panasonic estimate)
Shelf life 10 years at 21 °C (Energizer E91; 12 years on the newer E91 Max sheet)
Temperature
Charging temperature
0–40 °C · fast charge (Panasonic BK-3MCC)
Not rechargeable
Discharge temperature
from −20 to 50 °C · rated for use (Panasonic)
from −18 to 55 °C
Safety, charging and shipping
Charging
NiMH smart charger (2–3 hours) or 0.1C for 12–14 hours; trickle below C/40 (Energizer)
Not rechargeable
Uses
Typical uses
Remotes, toys, game controllers, camera flashes, wireless keyboards
Clocks, remotes, low-drain devices
Same on both (1)
Safety, charging and shipping
Air transport
Not restricted by air when the terminals are protected against short circuits (IATA special provisions A199 for NiMH, A123 for dry cells)
Can’t be compared (2)
Current
Maximum continuous discharge
Not stated in our sources
No rated maximum; internal resistance 150–300 mΩ when fresh (Energizer)
Safety, charging and shipping
Fire risk
Not rated here
Not rated here
Choose low self-discharge NiMH for
recharging: it is rechargeable, the other is single use
Choose alkaline cells for
a higher voltage that some devices need (1.5 V against 1.2 V)
What is the difference between low self-discharge NiMH and alkaline cells?
With low self-discharge NiMH: recharging. With alkaline cells: a higher voltage that some devices need.
Which lasts longer, low self-discharge NiMH or alkaline cells?
Recharge cycles for low self-discharge NiMH: up to 2,100 (IEC 61951-2:2011); 600 with the 2017 method (Panasonic). Storage for alkaline cells: shelf life 10 years at 21 °C (Energizer E91; 12 years on the newer E91 Max sheet).
Can I replace alkaline cells with low self-discharge NiMH?
In most devices, yes: both come as AA and AAA cells. NiMH runs at 1.2 V, so a few devices show a low battery early.