Between AGM and gel, 9 of the 16 characteristics in the full table below differ; 6 are the same and one can’t be compared because our sources give no figure or rating for one or both.
Rechargeable
Lead-acid AGM
2 V · 40 Wh/kg · 600 cycles
A sealed 12 V battery that standard chargers handle, and Fullriver allows charging down to −15 °C.
Watch out: Heavy (40 Wh/kg) and only 400 cycles at 80 % depth (Victron): deep discharges wear it out, and it should be recharged soon after use.
Rechargeable
Lead-acid gel
2 V · 41.5 Wh/kg · 750 cycles
The longest-lasting sealed lead-acid in Victron’s figures: 500 cycles at 80 % depth against 400 for AGM.
Watch out: Lower peak current than AGM (7C against 8C for 5 s, Victron), and it needs its own lower charging voltage.
Full comparison
Feature
Lead-acid AGM
Lead-acid gel
Differences (9)
Basics
Voltage range
1.75 V per cell at cut-off; absorption 14.2–14.6 V for 12 V (Victron)
1.75 V per cell at cut-off; absorption 14.1–14.4 V for 12 V (Victron)
Formats
12 V blocks; sealed, valve-regulated (VRLA)
12 V blocks; sealed (VRLA), with the acid in a gel
Example (source of the figures)
Victron AGM 12 V 90 Ah
Victron gel 12 V 90 Ah
Energy
Energy per kilogram
40 Wh/kg
41.5 Wh/kg
Life and storage
Cycle life
400 at 80 % depth, 600 at 50 %, 1,500 at 30 % (Victron)
500 at 80 % depth, 750 at 50 %, 1,800 at 30 % (Victron)
Current
Maximum continuous discharge
No continuous figure; 8C for 5 s at most (Victron)
No continuous figure; 7C for 5 s at most (Victron)
Temperature
Charging temperature
from −15 to 50 °C · with temperature compensation; 0–40 °C without (Fullriver); never when frozen
Not stated in our sources · temperature compensation needed below 10 °C (Victron)
Safety, charging and shipping
Charging
3-stage charger: absorption 14.2–14.6 V, float 13.5–13.8 V for 12 V; temperature compensation below 10 °C and above 30 °C (Victron)
Absorption 14.1–14.4 V, float 13.5–13.8 V for 12 V (Victron)
Uses
Typical uses
Leisure and backup batteries, UPS, alarm systems, starter batteries
Slow, regular deep discharges: solar, mobility aids
Same on both (6)
Basics
Type
Rechargeable
Nominal voltage
2 V per cell (12 V = 6 cells)
Energy
Energy per litre
101 Wh/L
Life and storage
Self-discharge and storage
Under 2 % a month at 20 °C, doubling with every 10 °C more (Victron)
Safety, charging and shipping
Fire risk
Not rated here; sealed (valve-regulated), so there is no acid to top up
Air transport
Non-spillable (UN2800): not restricted when it passes the spill tests of special provision A67 and the terminals are protected
Can’t be compared (1)
Temperature
Discharge temperature
Not stated in our sources
Not stated in our sources
When to choose AGM
In our table, no characteristic is in favour of AGM over gel.
With gel: more cycles. In our table, no characteristic is in favour of AGM.
Which lasts longer, AGM or gel?
Cycle life for AGM: 400 at 80 % depth, 600 at 50 %, 1,500 at 30 % (Victron). For gel: 500 at 80 % depth, 750 at 50 %, 1,800 at 30 % (Victron). These figures depend on depth of discharge, current and temperature.
Can I replace gel with AGM?
Yes as a 12 V battery, but set the charger for the new type: absorption 14.2–14.6 V for AGM, 14.1–14.4 V for gel.